7mm At the Western End of F7

AJC

Western Thunderer
:confused: really?

I understand why we are advised to not copy preservationists... I do not recall ever seeing the cab of ex-GWR / BR(WR) designs painted anything other than green and black.


I don't want to start a row, but I have at least one reason to cast some doubt on this. Now I grant you this is a bit of a contrasty shot, but the loco' is 1369, in BR service, dated, too and that looks like a cream/black divide on the cab front sheet (at least to me).

https://www.flickr.com/photos/96859208@N07/9547507229

It seems unlikely to have been a one off, but... See below for more informed comment! :)

Adam
 

Dog Star

Western Thunderer
Please be sure that you are not looking at the polished brass frame of the cab window... nor the (possibly) polished surface of the steam fountain.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AJC

oldravendale

Western Thunderer
I've just remembered a photo I took of the cab of a Modified Hall at Swindon in nineteen hundred and frozen to death. It was just ex works and had not been reunited with it's tender. (6930, Swindon Works Yard, May 1959). There's no indication that there was any light coloured paint in the cab above the waist line.

This is an interesting observation for me, too, as I tend to paint loco cabs a lighter colour above the waist line. Should've looked at my own references first!

Brian

6930.  Swindon Works Yard.  May 1959.  Personal Collection.  Final.  Photo Brian Dale.jpg
 

Scale7JB

Western Thunderer
A brilliant picture Brian !!

I'm rather fond of and know Halls quite well as I leaned to fire, and was passed out as a fireman on one, albeit an un-modified hall.

JB.
 

oldravendale

Western Thunderer
A brilliant picture Brian !!

I'm rather fond of and know Halls quite well as I leaned to fire, and was passed out as a fireman on one, albeit an un-modified hall.

JB.

One of my ambitions is a cab ride. There's nothing to stop me doing one on one of the preserved lines I guess. Just a question of getting round to it. It's all a bit clinical when compared with the BR days, though.

Actually, on reconsideration I think this is an unmodified Hall. Didn't the Modified Halls start at 6959?

As a side comment, when on the West Highland in 2012 I specifically looked in the cab of the Black 5 to see what colours it was painted. (In fact I was kindly invited on board by the crew). At first sight, despite the sparkling external appearance it appeared to be a uniform grey/black but on inspection the area above the waist was definitely lighter and when the grime was removed it was definitely cream above the waist line. I'm not suggesting that this is useful prototype information as the loco is preserved, but it rather demonstrates the need to look at loco cab photos ex works. Actually, I also believe that ex LMS locos were cream above the waist line in BR days, but I can't remember the reference for that!

While I'm at it here are some other cab photos of ex GWR locos (some are on my prototype photo thread already). You'll have to ignore the objective of these photos which was to record the backhead and controls within the limits of the camera I had at the time and concentrate on the cab sheeting which appears in the background of the shots.



4079.  Swindon.  23 May 1965.  Personal Collection.  Photo by Brian Dale.  FINAL No Correction.jpg

Firstly an unsatisfactory and out of focus shot of 4079 at Swindon on 23rd May 1965. It was immediately ex works and there's no evidence of a light coloured top bit of the cab.

6111.  Southall.  5 December 1965 FINAL.jpg

6111. Southall. 5th December 1965. This was at or just before witdrawal and there's no evidence of a light coloured cab - but in this case I'd guess there wouldn't be anything to indicate that, even if it actually was cream.

6143.  SECOND SHOT.  Southall.  5 December 1965.  FINAL.jpg

6143. Southall. 5th December 1965. Same situation as 6111 above, but the lighting is a bit better.

6859  Second Shot.  Southall.  5 December 1965.  FINAL.jpg

Same date, different loco and class. This is 6859, also at Southall.

9740 Cab.  Swindon Station.  May 1959.  Personal Collection.  Final.  Photo Brian Dale.jpg

Finally the cab of a working 9740 at Swindon Station in May 1959.

I have some from other regions too, notably the Southern. A West Country most definitely has a green cab interior, and that was a working loco at the time. It suffers the same problem, though, of seeing in detail what's above the waist line. However, there is some evidence that BR (SR) locos were painted a sort of bauxite above the waist. A colour photo I have of a BR (LMR) Jinty cab certainly suggests that this was cream above the waist line.

All in all it's a bit of a minefield. I suspect that, at least in part, the colour of the inside of the cab was decided to some extent at least by the local works despite what may have been written in any livery instruction manual. We know that, from time to time there were subtleties in different lining patterns, numberplate colours etc, so I don't see why that should not extend to the interiors of cabs!

I reckon Rule 1 applies. If anyone tells you that you have it wrong be very grateful as they obviously have the ex-works colour photo pre-1968! I'd love a copy for my collection.

Best regards.

Brian
 
  • Like
Reactions: AJC

mickoo

Western Thunderer
LMS/LMR locos were white / off white above the waist line, which quickly turned to a creamy colour, then steadily more brown as time passed and probably eventually almost black.

As far as I know, GWR/WR was always loco green inside the cab.

I'll check BR (standards) and LNER/ER later if needed, I suspect the Standards will be which ever workshop painted them, Crewe, Derby, Swindon, Darlington, Ashford etc.

Brian, yes modified Halls atart at 6950, nice photo BTW, saved to my collection for when I get around to modelling a Hall:thumbs:
 

Steph Dale

Western Thunderer
I'll check BR (standards) and LNER/ER later if needed, I suspect the Standards will be which ever workshop painted them, Crewe, Derby, Swindon, Darlington, Ashford etc.
Mick,
Do your photos of Evening Star support that hypothesis? Just interested. I also guess the WR locos carrying black had black cab interiors?
For completeness it appears that SR and BR(S) used a mid ochre for most of the upper cab sides and underside of the roof.
Steph
 

mickoo

Western Thunderer
Steph, no idea, at work so can't check my photos, but that's a preserved loco so their rule number 1 could apply;) which may mean it's not 'in revenue' authentic. To be fair, many preserved locos do try to recreate the originals, though you do get the odd one leaking through (lined 9F....which I thought suited them very well).
 

warren haywood

Western Thunderer
I've always done BR western region body colour inside cab including roof
LMR off white from a line level with bottom edge of window, black below.
SR, thanks to Steph and Richard, ochre top half, black below window/cab cut out
ER body colour but underside of cab roof off white
Standards dependant on which region it was built/overhauled.
Spent a bit of time looking into this and also confirmed it with Ian Rathbone, but there are always going to be contradictions

You should try pre grouping, absolute nightmare and most of em are lined inside!
 

westernfan

Western Thunderer
When I fired and drove the Dean Forest Railways BR Pannier 9681, the inside cab was all black . I have though painted the inside cab cream on my 7mm BR black 14xx ,because I liked it and it showed off the driver figure , but that's me . :rolleyes:
 

SimonT

Western Thunderer
Wotcha All! Unfortunately over the last three months I have only had time to take the odd look here while we were tied up in my father in laws terminal illness; you might imagine how some of the postings looked from our perspective. However, I have managed to do a little modeling and thought I ought to follow the rules and offer a photo or two. I have finally built a proper coach, a very different experience as I approached it in a new way. Someone, I think Adrian, had commented about how nice it was to see a coach build approached in the manner of a loco build. As a serial loco and wagon builder I hadn't thought of that approach as I don't do coaches. A phone call to Laurie gave me a new toy to play with and the progress is shown below.
IMG_1378.JPG

The instructions were of no use but I found some useful info at Chez Heather and the Part 3 book in the Wild Swan GWR Coaches book series of one. Now for the discussion point. The colour! My source is the following photo from Fred.
Western & Eastern Valleys. 028.jpg
All photographed in the yard at Aberbeeg but the colours are very interesting. As the red is a good match for the blood and custard I have painted the model blood red tinted with a bit of yellow to bring it closer to the colour in the photo. The maroon looks reasonably accurate so I am of the opinion that the red tones are close enough for government work. Thoughts and any info?

Simon
PS I know that the kit is the wrong diagram for the brakes in the yard but no one does a kit for the correct diagram.
 

Dog Star

Western Thunderer
As a serial loco and wagon builder...
The number of passenger vehicles in the yard suggests that you are about to become a serial carriage builder.
All photographed in the yard at Aberbeeg but the colours are very interesting... Thoughts and any info?
If this suggestion is any help... offering the photo to John Lewis could (a) identify the diagrams and (b) comment on the different reds to be seen - happy to pass his way if you wish.
 
Top