S scale posts seems to have petered out?..

Martin Field

Western Thunderer
I just had a look at the section which covers S scale and find that whilst 2014 was popular, this year there has been almost nothing. Is this the way it is or are there other places where S can be read about? I also like 7mm, so WT is a breath of fresh air, but it would be great to have some more on S scale.
 

JimG

Western Thunderer
Martin,

Since I am one of the S Scale brigade, that's probably down to me and one or two others.:) There are not that many of us in total and very few actually stick their heads over the parapets in the internet forums. Myself and others, like Scott Willis, frequent Western Thunder and one or two others frequent RMWEB, although most modelling threads seem to be on here. I am actually doing a fair bit of work in S scale at the moment but it is now mostly for the parts department and probably of little interest to others - like investigating 3D printing and casting, drawing up etches for things like "W" irons, and spending half of last week making track gauges. My most recent practical modeling in the scale has been my small US switching layout which featured over last winter. That's been done to NASG standards to match the US stock wheels and using spiked track, so probably not of much interest to you. :)

There's also a Yahoo email group where quite a few people pop up occasionally. It doesn't have a lot of traffic, but you normally do get responses quite promptly if you raise a thread in the group.

Yahoo! Groups

Watch out for the group name. There is a US group with the same name, but they use hyphens instead of underscores to punctuate the text.

I'm also splitting my time with a 1:32 scale layout in the garden, so whenever our summer weather allows, my modelling time is more concerned with civil engineering work in the garden. :)

I did have a passing thought about doing a cameo layout in S for the Wild Swan competition, but I decided that I would struggle to complete it in time so opted to consider a layout construction on an easier time frame. I've just got myself a larger car so I can now measure up to see what I can get in it. My previous car was a Citroen C1 which hardly gave room for a layout in a smaller scale. :)

Jim.
 

Martin Field

Western Thunderer
Thanks, Jim,
I didn't really expect a reply at all. It seems to be my way to automatically select scales that are rarely heard of, such as S and 5.5mm NG. Of course S NG would be perfect being almost spot on for 2 foot on 9mm gauge ! Assuming you can bear that tiny gauge, which I can't. Whilst N and 2FS seem to run well, OO9 never does.
I must say, American stuff doesn't really do anything for me as I have no knowledge of the country or its stock. I'm not familiar with the MRJ Cameo thing. I haven't seen an MRJ in a couple of years.

As to cars, mine is a Peugeot 206CC, so almost impossible to carry anything! They won't let me on RMWeb since I had right good old rant about that geezer who runs it.

It does seem a shame that S Scalers don't talk publicly. Oh well, plod on largely alone I guess.

Cheers.
 

JimG

Western Thunderer
Martin,

I didn't really expect a reply at all. It seems to be my way to automatically select scales that are rarely heard of, such as S and 5.5mm NG. Of course S NG would be perfect being almost spot on for 2 foot on 9mm gauge ! Assuming you can bear that tiny gauge, which I can't. Whilst N and 2FS seem to run well, OO9 never does.

Quite a few of our members model narrow gauge, but mainly overseas. I can think of New Zealand, Western Australia, Malasia, Sierra Leone and East African layouts at the moment. Cape Gauge (3' 6") prototypes are comparatively easy since they run on 16.5mm track so a lot of 4mm or HO parts can be used.


They won't let me on RMWeb since I had right good old rant about that geezer who runs it.

I think I was close to getting booted off a few years ago for arguing against the RMWEB lynch mob of the time and I don't contribute too much to it these days. I've learned to skim read the list of new posts and get very selective about what I read. :)


It does seem a shame that S Scalers don't talk publicly. Oh well, plod on largely alone I guess.

There is quite a bit of contact but it is usually by direct contact - phone, email, etc. And an S scale layout on show at an exhibition is an excuse for a mini-meeting. I do remember some exhibitions where there were enough members around a layout to form a quorum and call an EGM. :)

Jim.
 

Martin Field

Western Thunderer
Well, I couldn't get the drawings enlarged today because the oldest printers in town had taken the holidays together as it's a family firm and nobody remained who could 123% the drawing Neil kindly sent me, so I set to with the Proportional dividers and just got on with it. I'm not a patient man!

I now have a front end drawing of the Derby Lightweight in S Scale and enough on the bogie to start making a brass master of that. So we're off on a good start with this project. But I must now return to the Vincent for a few days.

Thanks for the responses Jim. I can see we are a select bunch<G>

Cheers.
 

Yorkshire Dave

Western Thunderer
I don't model S scale myself (mine is 1/4'' P48 US outline) however I suspect some of the parts produced for US S scale market could quite easily used for British outline S scale.
 

Martin Field

Western Thunderer
Not sure what they could offer Brits anything, Dave, except maybe some of the narrow gauge stuff.
1/48th tempted me, but English outline, just to poke a finger up to silly 1/43 and a halfth scale! If it ain't on my steel rule, I don't want to know. But I LOVE 5.5mm -1ft, which makes no sense at all. I suppose I should have settled on 5.5mm scale, Southwold Railway on 16.5 gauge.
 

ScottW

Western Thunderer
I must confess to not posting as regular as I once did. Over the last few years progress has been on the slow side so I have neglected posting anything online. I began a blog on RM web a number of years ago ScottW's Blogas I felt this format was better suited to my sporadic modelling style. But even that has fell be the way side.

Anyway, just to let you see what is currently on the go I have posted some pictures here http://www.westernthunder.co.uk/index.php?threads/whats-on-your-workbench.3804/page-62#post-156419

Scott
 

Jordan

Mid-Western Thunderer
Not sure what they could offer Brits anything, Dave, except maybe some of the narrow gauge stuff.
Agreed; there's not much cross-over of stuff in O scale, diesel loco wheelbase & truck (bogie) centre practises are waaaay out, for example.
I'd be tempted by UK S Scale if there was more R-T-R available. I know this is apostate heresy to most S Scalers, but I just don't have the time to scratchbuild almost anything, let alone everything!!! :)
In US outline I know there's stuff out there, but the range is even more limited than in 1:48, & also often blighted by 'hi rail'/3-rail standards :(
 

Martin Field

Western Thunderer
I'm afraid if my only option was to buy everything, I'd find another hobby! I couldn't derive any pleasure from having what so many others do. That would be the very reason to do S scale. That and the fact that the bits the society makes or has made for them are very affordable, wheras G1 stuff is way too expensive for me. I did once do a narrow gauge 1/32nd layout which I had no space for so I gave it away and the friend then died. I never got it back. Since you can now get so much in O gauge RTR and of course 4mm is pretty close to S, I'd say you're well catered for.
 

Martin Field

Western Thunderer
Jim, alas, Uckfield is probably even further! And to be honest, what I've seen of Trowland so far wouldn't see me travel far. I thought it looked a little clinical, even toylike, but that's only a few photos. It might be the wrong impression, but I don't expect black lines round buildings from one as well respected as Trevor Nunn. Maybe it still has a WIP status.
 
Top