Sorry Larry - but I have to disagree with this. I cannot believe that after all these decades we are having this conversation. The aircraft guys don't have this Prop Vs Jet rubbish. Are these just your opinions or statements of fact? They certainly are not true for me. I find a Class 60, 66 or 70 far more impressive to watch than a GWR Castle. But that is just my opinion. It is not for me to assume that is true for everyone else.Diesels are of little interest to many of us, although on a personal level, I made quite a bit of extra money out of photographing them at one time.
In one of his Ian Allan 1940s railway albums, O. J. Morris had slipped in a photo of a Southern electric unit to show that, no matter what he said it was doing, it was impossible to convey an impression of motion.
Photos of the steam locos, in contrast, are full of interest, probably because whether moving or not, they conjure up a period in railway history that we oldies remember, while diesels remind us of the downfall of the UK rail system, ~ Not just the motive power and rolling stock, but the whole infrastructure and a way of life.
I don't know if you get out on the railways today, but I don't see a system in that much decline, and in many areas, it is on the up. If there is no freight then why do we need so many hundreds of large freight diesels and electrics [with more being built] - and remember most of these classes have a much higher availability rate than any steam engine ever had. And why do we need all these new passenger trains? Watch the Beattock railcam for example, and the sheer frequency of Anglo-Scottish expresses on the move every weekday. Far more than ever, I'd say.
I find a large diesel with a heavy 2,200 ton freight train on the move every bit as impressive and moving as I used to find a Merchant Navy speeding through Brockenhurst with the Bournemouth Belle, as a kid. And as for the infrastructure and way of life part - it's just different. You can see the pride that workers took during the repair at Petteril Bridge Junction following the cement train derailment last year. Impressive work by any standards.
I've quoted him before, but as the Late US Railroader Don Ball Jnr. once wrote - as long as we're talking steel flanges on steel rails, then it's interesting.
As I've said before - I absolutely love Geoffs's layout and his presentation of it on WT - and Geoff, I apologise for the interjection!
DJP/MMP
Last edited: