So, back to cleaning brass, the Horolene arrived and was duly mixed as prescribed.
I decided to test one of the GTEL bogies with nigh on 35-40 years of tarnish.
It started out like this, pretty grubby in all honesty.
It went into the Horolene for a few hours, no change, not that I could be discern so decided to just leave it in there. checked again after three days, pretty much the same, pahh.
I reasoned it might still have the factory lacquer on so decided to dip in celly thinners, woah that made things change.
The right side is three days in Horolene, perhaps marginally cleaner in some areas, but the thinners really went to town and turned everything near black and that was only after a few hours. I couldn't scratch it off, it's much like a blacking agent....and I'll try it as just that on something else in due course. To be fair the next few tests did clean some of it back off.
The next step was five hours in Ketchup, bahh, waste of good ketchup, then two days in Coke a Cola, again total waste of time; it must be added that in between each test, and during each test, pages of web were browsed.....not sure what the benefits of rotting sand eels were as endorsed by one orator
The final test was a mixture of salt, baking soda, vinegar and aluminium foil....you guessed it, waste of good cooking materials and time.
In the end it looked like this.
Compared to the first photo it's actually got worse, I think it's safe to say that any wives tale or chemical cleaner touted by whom ever is just a load of
....I'd really love to be proved wrong....please do...
I did however come across some sage points, one live steam modelling forum wizened old gent had the perfect answer, don't use Brass! Brilliant and not wrong as far as I can tell.
The other point was on a clock forum, two point's actually, before you set out you have to determine if you want 'clean' or 'bright' brass, there's an important distinction between the two.
All of the above methods will give you 'clean' brass, none will give you 'bright' brass. Horolene will but it is wholly dependent on what the base metal was like before it tarnished. Polished brass as used in clocks will on the whole turn 'bright' again with Horolene; forty year old model train bogies will not, basically, as they say in computing circles,
in =
out
On a positive note I glass grit blasted these two items (the tank external only) earlier in the year, bead blasting will give a smoother surface as trialed on other items. The only down side to mechanical cleaning is time, you're looking at a good 90 minutes worth of effort in those two items.
If you want bright brass then there is only one sure way, mechanical cleaning, pure elbow grease.